Plant Protein Vs Whey – Protein Powder Types Compared

The pros and cons of plant protein Vs whey debate has surfaced since protein powders entered the fitness sphere. Both have their merits – whey is generally higher in protein content and absorbed quickly, while plant proteins can provide additional nutrients and be easier to digest for some. 

Rather than pitting them against each other, the healthiest approach may be enjoying a variety of quality protein sources and choosing what aligns best with one’s individual needs and fitness goals.

What Is Plant Protein Powder & What Is It Made Out Of? 

Plant protein powder is a popular dietary supplement made from plant-based sources, providing a concentrated dose of protein. The most popular ingredients in plant protein powder are soy protein, pea protein, brown rice protein, hemp protein, and various other plant-based sources such as pumpkin seed, sunflower, and mushroom. 

These powders are often used by vegans, vegetarians, and individuals with dairy or lactose intolerances as a convenient way to increase their protein intake. They can be blended into smoothies, shakes, or used in baking to boost the protein content of various dishes.

So, whether you’re vegan, lactose-intolerant, or just want more variety in your protein powder routine, plant-based proteins deliver quality nutrition from natural ingredients. 

Add plant protein powder to your pantry today!

BUY NOW

How Much Protein Is In A Serving Of Plant Protein Powder?

The amount of protein per serving in plant protein powders can vary quite a bit. But you’re guaranteed to get a good protein punch from each scoop. 

A 25g serving – about a large spoonful – of pea protein powder provides a whopping 20g of protein. That’s equivalent to three whole eggs! Soy protein powders contain around 22g per 25g serving. Hemp protein has approximately 15g per 30g serving. And you’ll get 10-15g of protein in a 30g scoop of brown rice or pumpkin protein powder. 

So whether you choose pea, soy, hemp, rice or another plant variety, you can easily meet your protein needs with one or two servings daily. Blended into a breakfast smoothie, stirred into oats or sprinkled onto salads, they make hitting your daily target a breeze. And plant proteins come with bonus nutrients not found in animal sources.  

What Is Whey Protein Powder & What Is It Made Out Of? 

Whey protein powder, a favourite among athletes and fitness enthusiasts, is derived from whey, the liquid by-product of cheese making. When cheese is produced from cow’s milk, it separates into solid curds and liquid whey. The whey, containing lactose, vitamins, minerals, and a bit of fat, is then pasteurised and filtered to concentrate the protein. This process yields different types of whey protein, such as concentrate, isolate, or hydrolysate, depending on the level of processing. 

Finally, the whey is dried into a powder form. Whey protein is highly valued because it’s complete, providing all nine essential amino acids necessary for muscle growth and repair. It’s also easily digestible if you do not have pre-existing gut conditions, and quickly absorbed, making it an excellent choice for post-exercise recovery.

Types of Whey Protein

Whey protein is available as whey protein isolate (WPI), concentrate (WPC), and casein. WPI, the purest form, suits those with lactose intolerance, offering over 90% protein with minimal fat and sugar. WPC, less filtered, retains more lactose and fat. Casein, thicker and slower to digest, is ideal for overnight muscle recovery.

Whey protein hydrolysate, a further broken-down form of WPI, absorbs fastest but tastes bitter.

How Much Protein Is In A Serving Of Whey Protein Powder?

Whey protein powders pack a powerful protein punch per serving. Whey concentrate contains around 24g protein per 30g scoop. Even more filtered forms like whey isolate and hydrolysate can provide 27–30g per serving. With its exceptional amino acid content highly bioavailable to build muscle and speed recovery, whey protein offers teenagers efficient nutrition to meet their high protein needs for growth and activity. Just one serving easily delivers nearly half of the daily recommended intake. 

Which Protein Is Better For You? Plant Protein Or Whey Protein?

With the growing shift from dairy due to lactose intolerance and other gut issues, plant proteins are becoming healthier for many active individuals. Though whey exceeds plant-based powders in bioavailability and muscle protein synthesis, pea, rice, and hemp proteins still deliver ample protein and muscle-building amino acids—especially soy. 

Balancing whey’s strength for workout recovery with plant proteins’ gut-friendly nutrition and micronutrients offers the best of both worlds: optimising muscle growth and lifelong health, easily achieved by varying one’s high-quality protein powder choice daily. 

For those avoiding dairy, turning to plants, or simply wanting sharp nutrition and variety, put plant proteins first. Their well-rounded nutritional profile supports fitness goals and overall well-being.

What are the Different Types of Plant Protein Powder?

Plant protein powders are increasingly popular, offering a range of options like Brown Rice Protein, Pea Protein, Faba Bean Protein, Soy Protein, and Hemp Protein. Each of these proteins brings unique nutritional benefits, catering to diverse dietary preferences and health requirements. 

The distinct characteristics of each plant protein type, underscore their importance in meeting the rising demand for plant-based nutrition solutions in both supplements and food products. These ingredients are essential for businesses aiming to address the varied needs of health-conscious consumers.

Brown Rice Protein:

Extracted from brown rice, it is a vital component in dairy-free products. It’s a commendable plant protein source, albeit slightly lower in lysine compared to soy protein. Its inclusion in protein powders ensures a comprehensive amino acid profile, catering to those seeking plant-based nutrition. This makes it an ideal choice for consumers looking for a wholesome and versatile protein source. Healthyroo’s protein powders are made using organic brown rice isolates and golden pea isolates.

Pea Protein:

Derived from yellow peas, pea protein like Healthyroo proteins is a cornerstone in many protein powders and vegan food products. Celebrated for its high protein content and easy digestibility, pea protein also stands out for its ability to replicate meat-like textures in plant-based alternatives. The use of pea protein in these powders guarantees not only nutritional excellence but also a satisfying culinary experience, appealing to a wide range of dietary preferences and enhancing the overall appeal of plant-based diets.

Faba Bean Protein:

Derived from Faba beans, this protein is gaining popularity in protein powders and meat substitutes. It’s known for its high protein and fibre content. Faba bean protein is less common than others but stands out for its rich amino acid profile.

Soy Protein:

One of the most common plant proteins, soy protein, is found in many products, including tofu, tempeh, protein powders, and meat substitutes. It’s a complete protein containing all essential amino acids, a major difference from most other plant proteins.

Hemp Protein:

Sourced from hemp seeds, this protein is found in protein powders and health food products. Hemp protein is rich in protein and omega-3 fatty acids, making it distinct for its additional nutritional benefits.

Pros and Cons of Plant Protein

Plant-based protein powders offer some unique advantages but also differ from traditional whey protein. Plus, they provide heart-healthy nutrition, antioxidants, fibre and ease of digestion. However, plant proteins tend to be less dense, providing fewer grams of protein per serving. They also offer less muscle-building leucine. Our selection balances sustainability, cost, taste and protein content to meet varying fitness goals.

Shop our quality plant powders that best match your needs.

Pros of Plant Protein:

• Heart-Healthy: Plant-based diets, often containing less saturated fat and more beneficial nutrients, are linked to improved heart health.
• Rich in Antioxidants and Fiber: These proteins offer antioxidants for combating oxidative stress and fibre for better digestion and gut health.
• Fewer Gastrointestinal Issues: Generally easier to digest, reducing gastrointestinal discomfort compared to some animal proteins.
• Eco-Friendly: Plant protein typically requires less water and land and generates fewer greenhouse gases than animal protein production.

Cons of Plant Protein:

The following have been a few Cons of Plant Proteins until now, however, plant proteins have taken a considerable leap in recent years and bridged the gap between their competitors:

• Cost: Plant proteins can be more expensive than animal-based proteins, reflecting higher processing and sourcing costs.
• Lower Protein Density: They usually have less protein per gram, requiring larger servings to meet protein needs.
• Fewer Ready-to-Drink Options: The market offers fewer convenient, ready-to-drink plant protein products than whey protein.
• Lower in Leucine: Plant proteins generally contain less leucine, an essential amino acid important for muscle synthesis and recovery.

Now, plant proteins offer a more affordable, sustainable option that aligns with modern health goals. Thanks to expanding consumer demand, the market continues advancing production efficiencies to lower costs. While plant proteins have comparatively less leucine than animal sources, combining proper supplementation with resistance training supports muscle development.

Healthyroo mitigates the so-called shortcomings of plant proteins through its superior blends. Not only health and fitness enthusiasts but also people across all walks of life have embraced the brand.

Healthyroo also empowers dietitians to help clients navigate plant protein options tailored to personal health objectives and lifestyle fit. Their Patient portals allow for ongoing collaboration setting and tracking protein targets.

Healthyroo also automates nutrition analysis so dietitians can easily develop recipes and meal plans optimizing plant-based protein sources for their clients’ needs. With data-driven, individualized guidance, plant proteins can effectively fuel plant-powered clients.

Pros and Cons of Whey Protein

Pros of Whey Protein:

• Faster Absorption: Whey protein is quickly absorbed by the body, making it ideal for post-workout recovery.
• Complete Protein: It contains all essential amino acids, making it a complete protein source.
• More Leucine Per Serving: Whey has a higher leucine content, crucial for muscle mass building and repair.

Cons of Whey Protein:

• Variable Protein Content: The amount of protein can vary significantly between different brands and servings.
• Potential for Fillers: Some whey protein brands may include excessive fillers, reducing the actual protein content per scoop.
• Stomach Issues: Whey can cause gastrointestinal discomfort for some people, though whey isolate is generally less likely to cause this issue.
• Not Vegan-Friendly: Being a dairy product, whey protein is not suitable for vegans.

Whey vs Plant-based Protein Powders Comparison

How They’re Made: Whey protein powder is derived from the liquid byproduct of cheese production. The protein is spray-dried into powder after removing carbohydrates, fat, and water. Whey contains lactose, a milk sugar, with whey isolate having less lactose than whey concentrate due to its processing.

Plant-based protein powders, on the other hand, are sourced from plants like brown rice, pea, soy, and hemp. These powders are ideal for vegans or those lactose intolerant, as they are dairy-free.

Protein Content and Amino Acid Profile:

•  Both whey and plant-based powders typically offer 20–30 grams of protein per serving. Whey is a complete protein, rich in all nine essential amino acids and branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs), crucial for muscle building.
• Plant-based protein powders vary in their amino acid profile, with soy being the only complete plant protein. Some plant-based products, such as Healthyroo proteins, combine two proteins to ensure a full amino acid range.

Digestibility and Food Sensitivities: Whey protein, containing lactose, may cause digestive issues for those sensitive to it. Plant-based powders might include allergens like soy and gluten, so checking labels is important. Some, especially those with pea protein, might cause bloating in sensitive individuals.

Suitability:

Whey protein is not suitable for vegans, as it is derived from animal milk, while plant-based protein powders are vegan-friendly and suitable for individuals with lactose intolerance or following a plant-based diet.

Even non-vegetarians can consume plant proteins.

Taste and Use:  

Some have often favoured whey protein for taste and easy baking. However, the quality and flavour of modern plant proteins now rival that, with options like soy, brown rice and pea boasting rich, creamy texture and versatility for smoothies, protein bars or baking. And with technologies improving rapidly, new plant-based formulations offer superior mixability, deliciousness and a range of tempting artisan flavours.

So plant powders now compete with whey in terms of both taste and versatility for tasty recipes while still being healthy.

SHOP NOW

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Whey Protein Better Than Meat Protein?

Healthyroo protein powders offer whey protein, a complete and rapidly absorbed protein, ideal for muscle recovery. While meat protein provides additional nutrients like iron and vitamin B12, whey is more convenient and efficient for immediate post-workout needs. The choice depends on individual health goals and dietary preferences.

Can You Gain Muscle With Plant Protein?

Absolutely. Healthyroo’s plant-based protein powders can effectively support muscle growth. Though lower in certain amino acids, a varied plant protein diet meets all essential needs, ensuring muscle development and repair.

Can You Take Plant Protein and Whey Protein at the Same Time?

Yes, combining Healthyroo’s plant and whey protein powders can be beneficial. This mix offers a wide range of amino acids and nutrients, catering to different absorption rates and health benefits. It’s an excellent strategy for those seeking to diversify their protein intake.